I’m wondering which one will last the longest from a durability standpoint. Which 1 will last : camping

Both serve a different purpose.

If you have a truck and your gear bags will be subject to water, go with the one on the right.

If your gear bags will be out of the weather and in a car/tent/cabin/etc the one on the left will be fine.

Properly cared for, both will serve their purpose for years.